Media Shower

We’ve all experienced that sinking feeling when we review our draft marketing campaign and think, “Is this actually good?” With AI tools, that uncertainty can multiply—because AI assistants will rarely tell you what’s wrong.

AI was built to be polite. Too polite.

Most AI tools are trained to be helpful, non-confrontational, and positive. That’s great when you’re looking for encouragement, but not so great when you need your marketing to soar.

That’s why one of the most powerful phrases you can add to your AI prompts is: “BRUTAL HONESTY.”

This simple command unlocks a more candid, direct assessment of your marketing, helping you see what’s working, what’s weak, and where to improve. 

In this blog, we’ll show you how to use this phrase effectively, including examples, follow-up prompts, and tips for marketers to get the most out of their AI assistants.

Watch the demo video below to see this strategy in action.


Step-by-Step Guide

Here’s how to get brutally honest feedback from your AI assistant:

  1. Provide your marketing sample. Paste in your draft article, email, pitch, or paragraph and ask for feedback.
  2. Add the command: “Be brutally honest.” This tells the AI you want a no-holds-barred critique.
  3. Ask for specifics. If needed, follow up with prompts like “What’s weak or boring?” or “Where would a reader lose interest?”
  4. Iterate based on the feedback. Revise your content and re-submit with “Be brutally honest” again.
  5. Repeat until your marketing rocks. Use this loop to sharpen your content with every pass.

Pro Tip: If you’re using the Media Shower AI marketing platform, your AI will know all about your company. In addition to sharpening your marketing, it can help you identify areas where your writing could be better aligned with your brand voice, UVP, or marketing goals. Click here for a free trial.

six stacked wooden blocks with comment emojis on them

Advanced Tips

  • Use it early and often. Don’t wait until the final draft. Ask for brutal honesty at the outline, draft, and editing stages.
  • Ask for rewrites. After you get feedback, ask, “Can you rewrite this paragraph to fix the problem you mentioned?”
  • Target specific areas. Try prompts like “Be brutally honest about the headline,” or “Be brutally honest about the call to action.”
  • Test for clarity. Use the phrase with: “Is anything unclear or confusing? Be brutally honest.”
  • Apply it to different formats. This works across blogs, email subject lines, CTAs, landing pages, and social captions. Anything where clarity and impact matter.
  • Balance the critique. You can also ask: “What’s working well here?” followed by “Now be brutally honest—what’s not?”

The goal is to make the AI feel like your toughest prospect—the one who’s not afraid to tell you that your opening is soft or your CTA is a yawn.

Real-World Example

Let’s see how “Be brutally honest” works for BrandCraft, a boutique copywriting agency.

Scenario: Natalie, a junior copywriter, is drafting landing page copy for a fintech client. She wants honest feedback before sending it to her manager.

Prompt: “Here’s my first draft of the landing page copy. Be brutally honest—what’s weak or unclear? At Finex, we help streamline your finances so you can focus on what really matters. Our intuitive platform makes managing money simple, fast, and stress-free. Whether you’re a small business owner or just looking for smarter solutions, Finex is here to help you take control of your financial future.”

AI Response:
“The opening sentence is vague and doesn’t hook the reader. Phrases like ‘streamline your finances’ are overused. The value proposition lacks specificity—how exactly does your service save time or money?”

Natalie revises and follows up.

Prompt: “I’ve revised the intro. Be brutally honest again—does it grab attention now?”

AI Response:
“Much better. The updated version has a clear benefit and a stronger voice. However, consider tightening the second paragraph—it repeats information unnecessarily.”

Natalie continues refining with pointed feedback until the copy is sharp, specific, and compelling.

Here’s how the final version reads:

“Ditch the spreadsheets. Finex simplifies your business finances with one smart dashboard—no math degree required. Save hours each week, track spending in real time, and stay compliant without the hassle.”

A massive improvement from where she started—and all it took was some honest AI feedback.

young woman in a yellow sweater smiling and crossing her arms

Marketer Takeaways

  • “Be brutally honest” transforms AI from a polite assistant to a ruthless editor.
  • Use it to catch weak ideas, flat phrases, and missed opportunities.
  • Combine with follow-ups like “Rewrite this section” or “Make it clearer” to turn critique into action.
  • Apply it across all formats—from landing pages to subject lines—for sharper, more effective content.

Media Shower’s AI marketing platform makes tough love easy, so you create marketing campaigns that crush it. Click here for a free trial.

More Tools for Busy Marketing Managers: